Spilt Milk · Step 1 of 4

Make the components. Shrub: stew 1 pound pitted cherries with 3 cups sugar until broken down, add 3 cups apple cider vinegar and 1 lemon peel, bring to a simmer, cool and strain. Milk liqueur: mix equal parts whole milk, sugar and vodka with half a lemon and half an orange, chopped; cover with cheesecloth for 10-12 days, stirring daily; strain until clarified.